Review: ‘The Bridges of Madison County, the Musical’

Following an inspirational research trip through Iowa, it
took college professor Robert James Waller just two weeks to pen “The Bridges
of Madison County” in the early 1990s. The book went on to become a New York
Times bestseller for three years, even outselling “Gone with the Wind.” A 1995
a film adaptation starring Clint Eastwood and Meryl Streep (directed by
Eastwood) pushed the story to even greater notoriety, and 2013 brought a
musical version for the stage, which is being presented through May 20 at JCC CenterStage.

“The Bridges
of Madison County” is a romantic novel narrated to resemble non-fiction, but
the story has no factual root. It’s set in 1965 farmland Iowa and follows the
four-day affair of Francesca Johnson, a 45-year-old Italian war bride who
became a lonely housewife, and Robert Kincaid, a 51-year old National
Geographic photographer who’s documenting covered bridges in the area. When he
stops at the Johnson residence to ask for directions, he meets Francesca, whose
husband and two teenage children are away at the State Fair for a few days. Francesca
and Robert kindle a whirlwind romance, and a choice must be made.

The musical
adaptation, with book by Marsha Norman (“‘night, Mother,” “The Color Purple'”)
and lyrics and music by former Eastman School of Music student Jason Robert
Brown (“Songs for a New World,” “Parade”) premiered on Broadway in 2014. That
same year, it won the Tony awards for ‘Best Original Score’ and ‘Best
Orchestrations.’

Though the
novel has a first person narrator (the author, a la “The Great Gatsby”), the
musical’s narrative is told through song. The show runs about two-and-a-half
hours — including a 15-minute intermission — and features more than 15 musical
numbers. In typical Jason Robert Brown fashion, the numbers range from the jazzy
“Get Closer,” performed marvelously by cast member Nancy Berg (Marge), to
soaring ballads like “Wondering,” which feels more like a poem: “But wouldn’t
it be fine to share/The weather in her eyes, her hair/Her footsteps as she
climbs the stair/The shadow in her light?” There’s even a little bit of gospel
(“When I’m Gone”) and honky-tonk (“State Road 21/The Real World”) to lend a
Midwestern twang.

Artistic
director Ralph Meranto has assembled a small but
mighty cast for this show. Much of the singing falls to Robert (played by
NYC-based Rochester native Mark Bradley Miller) and Francesca (played by local
resident Kristin Mellema). While Mellema’s
Italian accent is at times hard to decipher, her singing is strong and clear,
her intonations and characterization heartbreakingly authentic. Mellema is an ideal counterpoint for Miller’s Robert, and
the two have a convincing chemistry onstage, which is vital to the production’s
success. Miller is every bit the rugged wanderer, and while his vocals are less
polished than Mellema’s, it’s a satisfying contrast.

Rounding out
the cast are seven local actors who take on supporting roles and stage crew
responsibilities throughout the show. Standouts include the aforementioned
Nancy Berg as Marge; Colin Pazik as Bud Johnson,
Francesca’s well-meaning but slightly vanilla husband (Pazik
is clearly playing a character much older than he is, but does so with a little
aging makeup and a lot of aplomb); and Avery Carlson as teenage daughter Carolyn
Johnson. Carlson’s voice is easily the sweetest in the show, and she commands
the stage with her acting as well.

Design
elements are particularly strong, from Eric Williamson’s angular, rustic scenic
design to Diane Spacher’s colorful costumes and Laura
Fox’s bouffant wigs. The pit orchestra, led by conductor Casey Filiaci, never once overpowers the singers, but maintains a
complementary role throughout a musically demanding run.

When Robert
and Francesca are contemplating their affair, Roberts says, “I never go into a
world where people belong to each other.” That sentiment is an interesting
juxtaposition to the name of the show, which Waller may have intended as a
metaphor for the entire plot. Call it midlife crisis, loneliness, or romance —
but JCC CenterStage’s production of “The Bridges of
Madison County” will resonate with every audience member in some way.

This article appears in May 16-22, 2018.