If
you’ve been to a mall recently, you’ll be glad to know that the Department of
Homeland Security has got your back.
Or
to be more precise, they’ve thrown a few bones to the Monroe County Sheriff’s
Department to do the job. As the holiday shopping season was reaching its peak
in mid-December, the CountyLegislature approved
accepting a $50,000 grant from something known as the “Buffer Zone Protection
Program.” According to the legislation adopted by the Lej, the program’s goal
is “to prevent terrorist attacks and protect critical infrastructure
facilities.”
Apparently
the feds consider Marketplace Mall a “critical infrastructure facility.”
On
its way toward the floor of the full legislature, the bill stopped in the
Public Safety Committee, where Democrat (and incoming Minority Leader) Carla
Palumbo wanted to know more about the program and its seemingly unusual choice
of locations.
Sheriff
Patrick O’Flynn wasn’t able to tell her much, other than to point out that the
federal government — not his department — was calling the shots.
“This
project is part of the Department of Homeland Security,” he said. “They went
around and identified soft targets in our region and across the country and as
a result of that came to us as a law enforcement agency to see if we wanted to
apply for a grant, which we did.”
Asked
Palumbo: “How did you select Marketplace Mall as the location for this sort of
project?”
O’Flynn:
“It wasn’t for us to decide. The federal government decided for us and asked us
if we wanted to get into a strategy to address the issue of Marketplace Mall
being identified as being a soft target.”
Palumbo:
“I guess out of all the things that could happen in a community, it doesn’t
strike me that Marketplace Mall would be the one we would be the most concerned
about. There just seem to be a lot of other high-level areas — the Water
Authority comes to mind — just other things other than a shopping mall. But
maybe they were able to give you more of an explanation. That’s really what I’m
getting at.”
O’Flynn:
“It really was at their request. They identified these areas. Marketplace Mall
was one of them. Eastview Mall was another, in OntarioCounty. The Galleria
Mall in Buffalo was also
identified. It’s something the federal government did that we were offered the
opportunity to fund some security for that venue.”
Palumbo:
“So they were essentially looking at mall sites, or shopping sites where
there’s a high concentration of people?”
O’Flynn:
“I believe that was the issue. I believe that’s what they ended up doing.
Again, this was something that the federal government did and it came to us
with the option to fund.”
In other
words, as critics of Homeland Security spending have been complaining, the program is
little more than traditional pork-barrel spending wrapped in the guise of
national security. Of course, no one expects the Sheriff’s Department to turn
down free money from Washington, and given
the county’s budget constraints, the money will pay for some useful things.
Translation: it’s the good kind of pork.
“What
we envision doing with the grant,” O’Flynn told the Public Safety Committee,
“is purchasing Jersey barriers, a Morris capture station,
and an X-ray device for use in the mall.” Jersey barriers are
those concrete slabs that can be arranged to control the flow of traffic. A
capture station is a glorified computer terminal connected to the department’s
main network. It will allow deputies to process anyone they might arrest on
site (and check for a criminal record).
No
one seems to know whether Greece Ridge or the Medley Centre received similar
assistance. Federal DHS spokeswoman Anne Voigt told City Newspaper that was up to individual states.
“We
provide the funds to the state and then the state decides who receives them”
based on a priority plan the state drafts, she said. “For reasons of security,
the states don’t give out that kind of information.”
On
the contrary, contends New York State Office of Homeland Security spokesperson
Amy Fires, the state acts as nothing more than a pass-through agency for this
grant.
“NYS
OHS did not pick the sites for BZPP monies, the Federal DHS did. NYS OHS did not
prioritize which sites were chosen,” she wrote in an email. “We gave the same
amount equally to all sites that were chosen. NYS OHS had to give the monies
equally to all recipients.”
In
a follow-up phone message she added, “We do not give out the sites listed that
received the BZPP funds due to op sec reasons.”
Corporal
John Helfer, spokesperson for the Sheriff’s Department, confirmed that the
decision to protect Marketplace was made at the federal level, and that it was
probably based on the mall’s relatively high concentration of people. Helfer
also had no information on whether the other malls would benefit.
This article appears in Jan 4-10, 2006.
