The most anticipated theater of the fall season 

click to enlarge Rochester native Bruce Sabath, shown here on Broadway in "Fiddler on the Roof, in Yiddish," stars in “Searching for Tevye” at JCC CenterStage in October. - PHOTO PROVIDED
  • Rochester native Bruce Sabath, shown here on Broadway in "Fiddler on the Roof, in Yiddish," stars in “Searching for Tevye” at JCC CenterStage in October.
The rise of the delta variant of the coronavirus makes all plans for in-person gatherings feel precarious, so looking ahead to local theater productions we’re excited about this fall is a bit of a leap of faith.

But the intoxicating return of live performances this summer, largely at outdoor venues, has theater lovers banking on getting indoors when the weather turns, and a handful of companies are setting the stage for audiences.

The list of shows we think will be great includes timely revivals, intriguing new works, holdovers from the theater season that never was, and a mix of angels and ghosts and Mormons and McCarthyists, just to keep things interesting.

These upcoming shows, like everything in life nowadays, are tentative. Be sure to check theaters’ websites for updates and safety protocols.


Steppin’ Into My Shoes (Civic Ensemble’s Re-Entry Theatre Program; Sept. 11-25)

If the delta variant does end up ruining fall plans, or if you feel ill, here’s an opportunity for new theater that can be experienced remotely: The Ithaca-based Civic Ensemble and the College Initiative Upstate are collaborating to present a new play for the radio, developed from oral histories conducted in fall 2020 with people who have spent time behind bars. The piece centers the voices of those most affected by mass incarceration — a population that has been particularly vulnerable to COVID-19 — and aims to disrupt harmful stereotypes.

The radio play will air Sept. 11, 18, and 25 at 3 p.m. on WRFI 88.1 FM Ithaca and 91.9 FM Watkins Glen, and is also available via podcast at

click to enlarge vietgone_art_landscape_web.jpg
Vietgone (Geva Theatre Center; Sept. 28-Oct. 24)

Geva moves from its summer outdoor space to its first show on the Wilson Stage in 18 months with “Vietgone.” The play, by Qui Nguyen, was originally planned to be performed in May 2020, but . . . well, you know.

Known for his eclectic style, Nguyen co-founded a self-declared “geek theatre” company called Vampire Cowboys that draws inspiration from comic books and adventure stories. “Vietgone” is among his most critically-acclaimed shows and tells the true story of his parents’ journey in the United States after leaving Vietnam in 1975. The romantic comedy includes rapping, direct addresses to the audiences, and a perhaps soon-to-be-rare opportunity to see local work directed by Pirronne Yousefzadeh, who is leaving her position at Geva to become the producing artistic director of the Fine Arts Center Theatre in Denver.

Performances run Sept. 28 through Oct. 24 on the Wilson Stage at Geva Theatre Center, 75 Woodbury Boulevard. $25-$59.Tickets are available at or by calling 232-4382.


Searching for Tevye (Jewish Community Center’s CenterStage; Oct. 7-Oct. 10)

As part of the JCC’s season theme “Homecoming,” Brighton native Bruce Sabath has created an evening of showtunes, Yiddish music, and storytelling around his journey from a corporate strategy consultant to spending several decades as a theater actor with Broadway and off-Broadway credits. Prior to the pandemic, he played Lazar Wolf and understudied for Tevye in an 18-month run of “Fiddler on the Roof in Yiddish.” The show is directed by Tanya Moberly.

Performances of “Searching for Tevye” run Oct. 7 through 10 at the JCC Hart Theater, 1200 Edgewood Avenue). Tickets are available at or by calling 585-461-2000.

Much Ado About Nothing
(Rochester Community Players; Oct. 8-Oct. 16)

Director Carl Del Buono’s production of the beloved Shakespearean farce featuring the bickering Beatrice and Benedick is reset in 1913, when a group of British soldiers comes to California to marry wealthy American heiresses. The show involves some gender-swapped casting, with the villain Don Juan played by a woman and presented as Dame Jane.

“Much Ado About Nothing” is being staged at the Multi-use Community Cultural Center (MuCCC), which requires proof of vaccination for visitors 12 and older, and strongly encourages patrons to wear masks.

Performances run Oct. 8 through 16, with shows on Thursday through Sunday at MuCCC, 142 Atlantic Ave. $20 general, $15 seniors.

click to enlarge rent_8x8_graphic.jpg
Rent (OFC Creations Theatre Center; Oct. 8-Oct. 17)

Despite the overuse of the phrase “unprecedented times” in 2020, COVID-19 is not the first time Americans have endured an epidemic that was widely mischaracterized and mishandled.
The Centers for Disease Control have marked June 2021 as the 40-year marker of the first official reporting of the disease that would be known as Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome and is now HIV Stage III.

Jonathan Larson’s Pulitzer Prize-winning rock musical, directed by Judith Ranaletta, depicts a group of bohemian friends struggling to make art, keep love alive, and, of course, pay the rent, during the AIDS crisis.

Performances run Oct. 8 through 17, with shows on Friday through Sunday at the OFC Creations Theatre Center’s Main Stage, 3450 Winton Place. $35 general, $50 VIP.

Taking Shakespeare (Hummingbird Theatre Company; Oct. 28-31)

The Hummingbird Theatre Company specializes in lesser-known and lesser-produced plays, such as this 2012 two-hander by Canadian playwright John Murrell. Directed by the company’s founder Donald Bartalo, the play follows an aging professor and her academically failing student as they unexpectedly bond through reading and analyzing Shakespeare’s “Othello.”

Performances run Oct. 28 through 31 at the MuCCC, 142 Atlantic Ave. $15 in advance, $20 at the door.

click to enlarge haunting_of_hill_house_publicity.jpg
The Haunting of Hill House(Penfield Players; Oct. 29-Nov. 13)

Horror writer Shirley Jackson has had a presence in pop culture lately. “Shirley,” a bio-drama film about her starring Elizabeth Moss, was released last year, and her novel “The Haunting of Hill House” was adapted for Netflix in 2018. Director Jerry Argetsinger and the Penfield Players present a stage version of the novel, adapted by F. Andrew Leslie. The gothic tale follows a group of potentially psychic people who have been invited to an old house to be researched.

Performances run Oct. 29 through Nov. 13 at the Penfield Community Center, 1985 Baird Road, Penfield. $14 advance, $17 door.


click to enlarge angelsinamerica_showposter2021.jpg
Angels in America (RIT/NTID; Nov. 19-21)

If showtunes aren’t your thing, but you’re still open to high-concept fantastical theater, there’s another groundbreaking play about AIDS being staged this fall. Rochester Institute of Technology and National Technical Institute for the Deaf present Tony Kushner’s Pulitzer-winning play, directed by Andy Head, as its first in-person production since the pandemic began. Subtitled “A Gay Fantasia on National Themes,” the play features angels and ghosts while telling the stories of a closeted Mormon lawyer’s relationship to his wife and his colleague Roy Cohn, and a gay couple living in 1980s Manhattan.

The performance is in both ASL and English, performed by deaf and hearing students, and will also be captioned.

Performances run Nov. 19 through 21 at the Robert F. Panara Theatre, 52 Lomb Memorial Drive. Tickets are $12 general public, $10 RIT faculty/staff/alumni, $5 students.

Editor’s Note: CITY theater writer Katherine Varga works full-time as a real time captionist at Rochester Institute of Technology.

Katherine Varga is a freelance writer for CITY. Feedback on this article can be directed to Daniel J. Kushner, CITY's arts editor, at [email protected].
click image best_of_story_banner.png

English Country Dance

English Country Dance @ First Baptist Church

Richard Sauvain will be calling, to the lovely music of Molly, Mark...
Twenty Pearls: The Story of Alpha Kappa Alpha Sorority, Inc.®

Twenty Pearls: The Story of Alpha Kappa Alpha Sorority, Inc.® @ Little Theatre

To commemorate 116 years of service and sisterhood, please join us at...
Teen Comics Club!

Teen Comics Club! @ Brighton Memorial Library

Do you make comics or have you always wanted to? Join local...

View all of today's events »

Website powered by Foundation     |     © 2024 CITY Magazine