Would there have been fewer victims at Aurora if other theatergoers had been carrying weapons? An experienced cop says no. FILE PHOTO

Predictably,
in the days following the Aurora, Colorado, tragedy, some gun
enthusiasts have argued that if several theatergoers had been
carrying concealed weapons that night, they could have limited the
number of people killed and wounded. We heard the same suggestions
after the Gabby Giffords shooting and after the Virginia Tech
shooting.

It
was good to read in this morningโ€™s Times, then, the
op-ed
piece
by Michael Black, a former Chicago police officer.

Black
relates some of his own experience with armed criminals – and he
emphasizes the difficulty that well-trained, experienced officers
have when theyโ€™re faced with someone with a gun.

In
the Aurora theater, with the sights and sounds of the movie combining
with gunshots from a live person and a panicking crowd: โ€œEven a
highly trained armed police officer would have been caught off
guard,โ€ Black writes. โ€œTry adding a bunch of untrained, armed
civilians into the mix – this type of intervention could have made
things much worse.โ€

Mary Anna Towler is a transplant from the Southern Appalachians and is editor, co-publisher, and co-founder of City. She is happy to have converted a shy but opinionated childhood into an adult job. She...