Democrat Ted O’Brien is in jeopardy of losing his State Senate seat, if today’s Siena College Research Institute poll is to be believed.
The poll gives Republican Rich Funke, the former local news and sports anchor who’s challenging O’Brien, a 25-point lead. For the poll, 471 likely voters in the 55th Senate District were surveyed on October 1 and 2. Of the respondents, 37 percent were Democrats, 35 percent were Republicans, and 23 percent identified as members of other parties or no party.
“A long time and popular newscaster, Funke is better known and viewed far more favorably than O’Brien, even in a district with slightly more likely Democratic voters than Republicans,” Siena pollster Steven Greenberg said in a press release on the poll. “Funke’s got 84 percent of Republicans in his corner, compared to O’Brien’s 61-28 percent lead with Democrats. And Funke has a crushing 37-point lead with independents.”
But as with any poll, details matter, and a few caught my eye.
Of the Siena poll respondents, 49 percent were from Irondequoit, Penfield, and Rochester’s east side. Rochester is strongly Democratic, and Irondequoit has a pretty sizable Democratic enrollment advantage, plus it’s where O’Brien lives. But Penfield has a Republican enrollment edge. Of the respondents in this zone, 40 percent said they’d vote for O’Brien and 46 percent said they’d vote for Funke.
The south zone, which consists of East Rochester, Mendon, Perinton, Pittsford, Rush, and towns in Ontario County, made up 51 percent of the sample. It also went heavily for Funke: 67 percent of the respondents in this zone said they’d vote for him, compared to the 25 percent that said they’d vote for O’Brien.
O’Brien supporters also tend to be Cuomo supporters. Eighty percent of respondents who said they’ve voting for O’Brien also said they have a favorable view of the governor.
Another interesting fact: respondents said they prefer a State Senate controlled by a coalition of Democrats and Republicans to a chamber controlled by one party.
The poll doesn’t shed much light on the issues that might be influencing the race. It says that most respondents ranked jobs as the most important issue for state senators to work on in Albany. State taxes, property taxes, and education were also top choices. But it’s a safe bet that the district has a constituency opposed to the SAFE Act. O’Brien voted for and strongly supports the act.
Abortion rights opponents, as well as Funke supporters, have been airing ads attacking O’Brien for his support of abortion rights legislation. The ads claim that O’Brien supports legislation that would permit abortions through the final month of pregnancy and would allow non-physicians to perform abortions.
O’Brien does support the abortion rights plank of the Women’s Equality Agenda. The legislation basically takes the protections guaranteed in the Supreme Court’s Roe v. Wade decision and spells them out in state law. It would make clear that women have the right to access abortions through 24 weeks of pregnancy. And it also spells out that women can have abortions later in their pregnancies when their health and life is in jeopardy, as determined by a licensed physician, which is also provided for under Roe v. Wade.
New York’s laws allowing abortions predate Roe v. Wade and are included in a section of state criminal law (the Women’s Equality Act would move those statutes into a section of state public health law). New York laws already allow women to get abortions through 24 weeks of pregnancy, and include an exception for life of the mother. But it doesn’t include the health exception, even though Roe v. Wade requires it.
The 10th point of the WEA does not allow for partial birth abortions, and does not expand when women can get abortions and who can provide them.
This morning, O’Brien’s campaign sent out this statement from campaign spokesperson Jamie Romeo in response to the poll results:
“These very early numbers are not surprising considering Rich Funke’s 40 years as a local celebrity and the hundreds of thousands of dollars he’s spent lying about Ted O’Brien while he’s had the playing field all to himself. Now that the campaign has truly begun, voters will get to know the real Rich Funke and hear about his extreme, anti-women views. By Election Day, it will be clear to Monroe and Ontario County residents that Ted O’Brien is the only candidate in this race who shares their values. Ted O’Brien’s record of creating jobs, cutting taxes, and fighting for women’s equality will lead him to victory on November 4.”
SD410914_Crosstabs by jmouleatcity
This article appears in Oct 1-7, 2014.
Module and Romeo may not like the results reported by Siena today, but they are likely fairly accurate. One only has to go back to the Slaughter/Brooks contest two years ago, where the vote split was only about 3% different than the poll, so within the margin of error. It is no surprise that Dems favor O’Brien and Reps favor Funke. The big surprise is how much Independents favor Funke. O’Brien barely won in 2012, when Obama was on the ticket and was fairly popular. This year, he is missing. Most people in the poll seem to have liked the results of having the Reps, with a small group of Dem’s, provide a balance to the left wing tilt of the Assembly. My guess is that O’Brien should dust off his resume, as he is likely to be without a job in January.
Funke does not show up at debates, therefore I conclude he does not respect voters. Or he does not trust voters to vote after they learned about him.
He has no plan to curtail gun violence. He does not believe a woman has a right to choice in health care. Funke is the wrong candidate.
Vote for O’Brien.
Voters should ask Funke and Reilich why their candidates routinely blow off debates and only go to friendly media outlets (usually far right) where they’ll be tossed softball questions with no tough follow-ups.
What are they afraid of?
“Funke does not show up at debates, therefore I conclude he does not respect voters”
Ted O’Brien votes for (rubber stamps) Cuomo’s ‘NY SAFE ACT’ no input from constituents and no debate or discussion. He’s the one who does not respect the voters. Pack your bags and clean out your desk, Ted!
Riche Funke decides voters are not important….he misses another debate.
My I offer an opinion… O’Brien will be getting my vote because he has specifically identified where he stands on all the issues in his district. O’Brien has experience and a track record. Funke has no track record; has never been involved in Govt’; was chosen by his party because he has a track record in broadcasting without any experience in Govt’ policy or planning. Funke may win but he has no experience. So ask yourself one question…do you want experience or popularity. I’ll take O’Brien’s experience.
Craig R. Moffitt
The problem with O’Brien is that he has yet to introduce himself again to voters. Yeah, he’s a state senator. BIG deal. Most people in Rochester barely know who the governor is and routinely have no clue who’s their congressional representative (everyone ALWAYS has assumed it’s Slaughter, even before her redistricting, when Monroe County was carved into four separate districts).
Funke has the advantage b/c he’s a well-known media “personality”, whereas O’Brien who is a good decent man, is being tagged as an “Albany politician”. The response to that should be: News flash, when you are in the state legislature, it meets in Albany. And when you are elected to political office, you’re a politician. If you want to serve people, go wait on the elderly at a retirement home. When you are in politics, you are a politician. O’Brien was the county Democratic chairman for two years, a county legislator for eight years (the legislative minority leader for the last two years) and a state senator for the last 22 months. O’Brien should be re-elected b/c he deserves it.
Ted is familiar with the Monroe County part of his district but apparently not with the Ontario County part. If he was he would have known that his vote for the SAFE Act would turn any rural voters who voted for him two years ago against him. If he had voted no or abstained he might be heading for a second term. Voting yes went against at least half of his constituency. A drive to Naples shows the proof with anti-SAFE Act signs lining the roads. Ted believes in the SAFE Act, fine, but it’s hard to believe he didn’t know what a hornet’s nest it would stir up in the rural southern half of his district.