House party 

Rochester's off-off-really-off-Broadway performance venues

click to enlarge theater.jpg

For a city of Rochester's population size and general distance from the Great White Way, there's an impressive amount of talent and options for theatre lovers. But while the bigger houses like Geva, Rochester Broadway Theatre League, and Blackfriars get plenty of love for their season-long programming, there's something to be said for the scrappier upstart houses that host roving companies and pop-up shows throughout the year. Here's a comprehensive look at the go-to spots for live performances, from theatre to comedy.

It's still worth mentioning Rochester Broadway Theatre League (RBTL), which is as close to Broadway as local folks can get without booking a trip downstate. RBTL is housed in the Auditorium Theatre (885 East Main Street, and hosts a full season of touring Broadway productions from larger markets as well as one-off events such as Blue Man Group and Jerry Seinfeld live. Geva Theatre Center (75 Woodbury Boulevard, is the city's sole regional professional theater, and does equity casting in New York City, with the occasional need for local actors. However, all of Geva's shows are designed, built, and teched by its own (local) staff. And while Blackfriars Theatre (795 East Main Street, doesn't use equity actors, it does cast all of their productions from the massive talent pool in town, and everyone involved in a show is paid.

click to enlarge A scene from Blackfriars Theatre's 2019 production of "Detroit '67." - PHOTO BY ROY HEERKENS JR.
  • A scene from Blackfriars Theatre's 2019 production of "Detroit '67."

The Multi-use Community Cultural Center (MuCCC), which was opened in 2009 by arts entrepreneur and local theatre enthusiast Doug Rice, is a home for new companies or companies that don't have a permanent space. Housed in an old church (142 Atlantic Avenue, MuCCC can be rented for a weekend (or more) of performances. The center also produces a few events of its own: MuCCC Fest, a celebration of local performers; New Plays, New Voices, a playwriting reading series; Dances at MuCCC; and This is Our Youth, which showcases city students.

Deep inside the Village Gate complex, on the second floor of the main building, is The Avaryium (274 North Goodman Street,, a blackbox theater that's home to WallByrd Theatre Company and rents space to other small troupes around town, such as Grey Noise Theatre Co. The Avyarium is located within walking distance from the Village Gate's many restaurants, which makes dinner and a show especially convenient. During September, it also functions as a Keybank Rochester Fringe Festival venue.

Bread & Water Theatre (172 West Main Street, has been around for 20 years, but beats a quiet drum. The company's space is on the outskirts of downtown, and founder J.R. Teeter keeps a strong commitment to theatre works that reflect the cultural pulse. This year, Bread & Water is hosting "The First and Final Word Playwriting Contest" in September. Entrants are encouraged to submit original plays of any length for consideration by May 1.

click to enlarge Hummingbird Theater Co. presented "The Amish Project" at The MuCCC in the fall of 2019. - PHOTO BY ANNETTE DRAGON
  • Hummingbird Theater Co. presented "The Amish Project" at The MuCCC in the fall of 2019.

One of the newer venues in town is The Avenue Blackbox Theatre (780 Joseph Avenue, Founded by artist and arts advocate Reenah Golden in 2018, The Avenue brands itself as "an inclusive, fully accessible, queer space where social justice and art disciplines converge to create dynamic stage productions, installations and live art-making events." In the almost two years it's been open, The Avenue has instituted youth programming, merchandise, and regular exhibits in addition to performances.

Housed in a former Christian Science church building, Lyric Theatre (440 East Avenue, boasts an ornate 700-seat auditorium as well as a smaller cabaret theater. Right now, it's the primary residence of OFC Creations, a youth theatre ensemble that focuses on K-12 day camps and performances. The Lyric also has its own educational initiatives — some focused on opera — and produces solo music performances and shows by Hands In Entertainment, a troupe that performs in American Sign Language (ASL).

Another venue worth mentioning — though a little further from downtown — is the newly renovated Kodak Center (200 West Ridge Road,, where patrons can see everything from touring children's theater and comedy acts to locally-produced musicals. Performances by big stars (such as Fran Drescher's one-woman memoir show this season) also grace the stage from time to time. OFC Creations also holds a theater summer camp at Kodak Center for ages 4-18. In addition to the auditorium, the Kodak Center Visitor Center has rotating photo exhibits, a gift shop, and cafe.

In This Guide...

  • Mark Your Calendar

    ...but use a pencil
    As of the printing of this publication, 2020 hasn't unfolded as expected. We hope the health crisis is short-lived and that, when it's all over, Rochester will get back to its routines and showcasing its treasures.

  • Shelf-aware

    A peek into Rochester's literary scene
    Rochester's got many organizations and literary centers that support its crowd of authors, poets, and lit-loving audiences.

  • Exhibit A+

    A survey of Rochester's museums, galleries, art studios, and public art
    Rochester is regularly called a "city of the arts" by politicians and cultural movers and shakers alike.

  • A renters' rights run-down

    Some recent, high-profile cases of negligent landlords, along with an explosion of new high-end apartment complexes with equally high-end rents, have brought issues of housing and renters rights to the fore.

  • A guide for all seasons

    You might think you know all there is to know about your hometown, but you can live in a place your entire life and learn something new about it every day. That's what CITY's Annual Manual is all about.

  • From ale to weisse, Rochester brews it

    The Flower City loves beer and there's no shortage of fresh, local brews.

  • For the kids

    Family-friendly options in Rochester
    If there is one constant theme to greater Rochester, it's that the area is a great place to raise kids.

  • Take me to your leader

    Greater Rochester saw a lot of changes in its political scene in the last year.

  • Moving the needle

    As the third-largest city in New York, Rochester has a rich local media scene, with a daily newspaper, a feisty alternative news weekly, three network television news affiliates, and dozens of radio stations.

  • The sites for sounds

    A curated guide to essential local concert venues
    Location is everything when it comes to seeing music performed live.

  • Welcome to the neighborhood(s)

    When we talk about "Rochester," we're not just talking about the city.

  • Dive into the nightlife

    As the old Willie Nelson song goes, "The nightlife ain't no life, but it's my life."

  • Susan B.'s Big Year

    Rochester has grand plans to celebrate its favorite daughter — Susan B. Anthony — and her accomplishments throughout 2020, a year that marks a trifecta of important anniversaries.

  • Weed in the Flower City

    Let's make one thing clear off the bat: Recreational cannabis was not yet legal in New York as of this guide's publishing.

Latest in Annual Manual

Rochester NY VMUG February vBeer @ RSBC - The Mill

Join Rochester NY VMware User Group (VMUG) for our first event of...
May December

May December @ Little Theatre

Twenty years after their notorious tabloid romance gripped the nation, Gracie (Julianne...

The Harley School's Middle School Open House @ The Harley School

An on-campus Open House is a great way to learn about The...

View all of today's events »

Website powered by Foundation     |     © 2024 CITY Magazine